Thanks Pual! I double checked all the settings and they were matched on both ends. I used Wirecast to view the BM input just because it was the fastest way to change input resolutions, but I also used Media Express to no avail. After lots and lots of digging, it turns out there is an issue either with the Catalyst Control Software of ATI video cards, or the cards themselves with Black Magic Devices, and for some odd reason it wasn't working. I picked up a cheap Nvidia Graphics Card on Amazon and set it all to the same settings, and it worked like a charm the first time. So for anyone having an issue, turns out it might be the video card.